Reviewer:Max Reiner -
October 25, 2014 Subject:
Very High Production Values
I was struck by the very high production values in this film. Just a few examples here. Things like several camera angles taken on a bus. One was through the window as passengers got off. Then a high angle as the femme fatale got off and walked down the street. Lots of cutaways during two-shots between Holmes and Watson in the detective's flat. One night shot during day had a strong light in a basement window to enforce the illusion in was night. Indeed, a whole bunch of details we rarely see nowadays. Nowadays it's a lot of cutaways to maintain visual interest. Thus, I give it the highest rating for camera and other production values.
One more thing, Patricia Morison as the femme fatale going after the music boxes--see her remarkable bio in Wikipedia. She went on to star on Broadway. Was a mezzo soprano. Astounding lady!
Reviewer:The oldies guy -
November 17, 2012 Subject:
Rathbone and Bruce...perfect
I've enjoyed listening and watching the adventures of Sherlock Holmes for many years (over 40). To me Basil Rathbone IS Sherlock Holmes, as is Nigel Bruce as Dr Watson. Perfect casting.
November 16, 2010 Subject:
A must see
watch this !!
November 16, 2010 Subject:
I'd say rathbone is a perfect holmes and nigel complements him very well. i have seen all of his works. classic. :)
September 12, 2010 Subject:
Another Wonderful Sherlock Holmes Adventure with Basil Rathbone & Nigel Bruce
I really enjoyed this Sherlock Holmes movie with Basil Rathbone and Nigel Bruce. The main and supporting actors, the dialogue, and a good plot all served to make this entertaining. These movies are very much appreciated. The radio counterpart is also worth listening to on the Internet Archive.
January 31, 2010 Subject:
Whistle a Happy Toon
Yes I know this isn't one of the wonderfully faithful BBC/PBS adaptations, and it is based more on Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's characters than his story. Nevertheless, Universal's modernized Sherlock Holmes yarns have an appeal all their own, and this one is no exception. The plot involves murder, music boxes and a scheme that could threaten the stability of the British Empire. Basil Rathbone's Holmes is brilliant as ever, and Nigel Bruce is engaging as the ever-bumbling Dr. Watson. It all adds up to seventy-two minutes of sleuthing fun. (a.k.a. Sherlock Holmes in Dressed to Kill)
January 23, 2010 Subject:
Wonderfully classy and truly authentic British production
I've been to Samuel Johnson's house (it is still a museum as it was in the movie 63 years ago) where the last scene takes place, and the film makers either used the real interior or did a magnificent job of reproducing it, down to the last detail. By the way, the attic room where the final action takes place was also where Dr. Johnson compiled the first English dictionary.
An interesting plot. Several suspense moments. I easily give it five starts.
May 17, 2009 Subject:
Thanks Holmes! Live like him!
Its a fact of life that one day I will be dead so will you. There is no thing can do to stop this. However we can make the most of our time on this earth. Doing something useful with our time here can help other and it also give us a sense of purpose and our life some meaning. You only live one, this is a not rehearsal. Life is like a big performance and one the curtain has come down on it there will be no encore. So we should live like him (always help other) and our life some meaning.
July 25, 2008 Subject:
I too am a big fan of the Basil Rathbone movies about Sherlock Holmes. This one is great too. Although the sound and image are quite clear, this particular print is so unstable that it distracts me from a great story. Maybe there's some kind of video software out there that could help?
September 22, 2007 Subject:
I first saw the Holmes series with Basil Rathsbone and Nigel Bruce and liked it so much I bought the collection. I've seen them all many times and still enjoy watching them.
September 21, 2007 Subject:
Good story,and very nice to watch.Most of the time I was afraid someone would walk through the cardboard walls.
March 8, 2007 Subject:
the swan song for Basil Rathbone
This film, eventhough it is enjoyable to watch:is the last film Mr. Rathbone for Universal Pictures as Holmes. I felt at this time "the Holmes character is strankling my creative force as an actor." A shame to see but we are glad he did what he did to Mr. Holmes to life for so many to enjoy. Please get as many as you can IA of these gems of Holmesania.
I was introduced to the Basil Rathbone/Nigel Bruce Sherlock Holmes series when I was about nine or ten. I had a terrible flu that year that dragged on and on, and to console me, my father brought the entire series home from the video rental place for me to watch. Even though I didn't understand many of the subtleties, I adored them. I'm so happy to discover that these movies are just as good as I remember.
January 8, 2007 Subject:
Typical Sherlock Holmes Rathbone-Bruce fare
Basil Rathbone is known for two dramatic roles: the villain, and when he's not the villain, Sherlock Holmes. If you're a fan of the old time radio show sponsored by Petri Wine, then you'll definitely enjoy these films. Even though Bruce's Dr. Watson is far more of a mumbling bumbler than in Doyle's stories, to many, he's the archetypal Watson. Rathbone seems born to play Sherlock. I encoded this to a Video CD since I don't have a DVD burner, and the quality is quite watchable on my 20 inch TV and budget DVD player.
The stories aren't true to Doyle's works but are quite enjoyable nevertheless. Before there was Jermey Brett as the "perfect" Sherlock Homes there was Basil Rathbone, and he certainly rates up there with Brett, and Peter Cushing as one of the great "Homes" of all time. Worth watching.
February 16, 2005 Subject:
Brian de Palma's Dressed to Kill is not a remake of this!
Quite an intersting plot make this Sherlock Holmes movie interesting to watch. A worthy Antagonist to Sherlock leads to a duel of wits.
While on the one hand the level of sophistication within the story is high, some crudeness in characters (mainly the Chaffeur is a posterboy for a cliche) let the movie a little down.
3 Stars for the actors, 5 Stars for the plot makes an even 4!
Have fun !
July 2, 2004 Subject:
More of these PLEASE!
I love the old Sherlock Holmes films. I have them on old video tapes, I have some (when I've been able to find them) on DVD. But this downloaded version was of higher quality than DVDs that I PAID for!
I hope more of these get preserved digitally by people who care about the quality of the work. No clicks, pops, or gaps in the film on this one.